Prognostic Comparison of Statistical, Neural and Fuzzy Methods of Analysis of Breast Cancer Image Cytometric Data

This paper aims to predict a breast cancer patient’s prognosis and to determine the most important prognostic factors by means of logistic regression (LR) as a conventional statistical method, multilayer backpropagation neural network (MLBPNN) as a neural network method, fuzzy K-nearest neighbour algorithm (FK-NN) as a fuzzy logic method, a fuzzy measurement based on the FK-NN and the leave-one-out error method. The data used for breast cancer prognostic prediction were collected from 100 women who were clinically diagnosed with breast disease in the form of carcinoma or benign conditions. The data set consists of 7 image cytometric prognostic factors and 2 corresponding outputs to be predicted: whether the patient is alive or dead within 5 years of diagnosis. The LR stratified a 5-factor subset with a prognostic predictive accuracy of 82%, while the highest predictive accuracy of the MLBPNN was 87% obtained from two subsets. In this study, the FK-NN yielded the highest predictive accuracy of 88% achieved by eight different subsets, of which the subset with the highest fuzzy measurement was {tumour histology, DNA ploidy, SPF, G0G1/G2M ratio}. Although the three methods resulted in different models, the results suggest that tumour histology, DNA ploidy and SPF, which are included in all three methods, may be the most significant factors for achieving accurate and reliable breast cancer prognostic prediction.